American Idol: They Said What?

Updated: June 2, 2008

By Charli Schuler
Design by Jack Nealy

Jennifer Hudson implied it was mentally abusive. Katharine McPhee said it was "controlling." Clay Aiken called it "boot camp" for the entertainment world. Do you think "American Idol" is too mean for TV, or is it all just showbiz? Get a recap of what the judges have said before you decide.