puerto rico
September 24, 2013

Puerto Rican Statehood


Scott: Yesterday, we took you to Puerto Rico where people are considered American citizens but don’t have the same rights as people who live in the continental U.S. So, what will become of the island and its residents? Well, Shelby Holliday brings us day two from Puerto Rico.

Shelby: You all agree that something needs to change?

Teens: Yes

Shelby: Why?

Gabriel Gonzalez: We are a colony. We have someone always pushing us down.

Shelby: These teens are all U.S. citizens from the U.S. territory of Puerto Rico, but they say they aren’t treated like other Americans.

Nicole Burgos: Right now we have, like, a secondary type of U.S. citizenship. We can’t vote for Congress, vote for the president or anything like that.

Kevin McClintock: I find it extremely unfair that a president for which we are denied the right to vote and a Congress in which we lack voting and proportional representation can reinstate a draft and send me to war as soon as tomorrow.

Shelby: The territory’s status and citizenship rights have been hotly debated for decades. Even though people in Puerto Rico don’t have to pay federal taxes, they can’t vote for president, and they don’t have an elected representative with voting rights in Washington, D.C.

Puerto Rico has been governed by the United States for more than a century. But in a vote taken last year, a majority of Puerto Ricans said they do not like the island’s current political status.

Pedro Pierluisi: That changes the dynamics of the discussion of the status of Puerto Rico forever.

Shelby: Pedro Pierluisi represents Puerto Rico in Congress. He can’t vote on House bills, but he can introduce legislation.

Pierluisi: So, Puerto Rico status.

Shelby: In response to last November’s vote, he started pushing for a new bill called the Puerto Rico Status Resolution Act.

Pierluisi: The purpose of the bill is to set forth the process for Puerto Rico to become a state of the union.

Shelby: Pierluisi says last year’s vote showed that most Puerto Ricans want the territory to become the 51st state of America. But it is up to the people there to officially decide, so his bill is calling on Congress to approve a federally authorized vote.

Pierluisi: Sooner or later, Congress will have to act because the U.S. is the most democratic nation in the world. And what’s democracy if not government by the consent of the governed?

Shelby: Pierluisi hopes Puerto Rico can follow in the footsteps of Hawaii and Alaska, two former U.S. territories that became states. But it is not as simple as taking a vote. Congress would have to pass a law admitting Puerto Rico to the union, which experts say is unlikely. And if Puerto Rico became a state, it would cost the U.S. billions of dollars a year in federal programs. Furthermore, uniting Puerto Ricans would be a challenge. Even though most are demanding change, they have divided ideas about the future. Some think the island should be its own country.

So, Gabriel, you want independence? Why?

Gabriel: I want to be free of having a country telling us what to do. It’s also for us to grow economically.

Shelby: Others say Puerto Rico should become a state.

Kevin: The vast majority of us have grown up, and our parents have grown up, being part of the United States, and we deserve to be part of the United States with our full citizenship rights.

Shelby: And some want free association, which would give Puerto Rico sovereignty but keep a relationship with the U.S.

Nicole, you want a better version of the status quo?

Nicole: I do not think that being a state would really help us, but being independent would take such a long time that I’m afraid we might lose sight of what we were searching for. And I think this is a good compromise.

Shelby: So, what will the future of Puerto Rico look like? If the status resolution is passed, voters will have a say.

Pierluisi: Congress has to be straightforward with Puerto Rico. Statehood is one option, and Congress can lay it out like I have proposed. This is the most democratic nation in the world. It should lead by example.

Shelby: Shelby Holliday, Channel One News.

Scott: The proposed bill for Puerto Rico statehood is on hold and awaiting a hearing in the House of Representatives. We will keep you posted on its progress in Congress.


10 comments on “Puerto Rican Statehood

  1. Hunter H.

    No, because the U.S. will have to pay billions of dollars a year, so no Puerto Rico shouldn’t be the 51st state.

    -Hunter H.

    1. Saulo M. Gimenez

      Is the United States really going to have to pay billions? The way I see it Puerto Rico would have to pay federal taxes which as I believe you can imagine is more than a billion dollars and not only that but Puerto Rico is not allowed to import from any countries other than the United States and the exports from the United States are one of, if not the most expensive exports in the world from gas to food it all comes from the United States and it is all paid for by Puerto Rico. Those billions of dollars that you speak of more than half of that are already being paid we the citizens alone to the United States of America.

  2. Saulo M. Gimenez

    Yea because you would like the fate of your home to be decided by people whom you’ve never met and could care less about a little island in the caribbean but frankly since this is not your home I respect your opinion but I believe that it is a display o how severely oppressed we the people of Puerto Rico are by people like you thank you for providing proof that what is stated in the interview, about us not being treated equally even though we are citizens, is true.

  3. Gabey

    Puerto Rico should not become a state because, well, I don’t even know what a state is. It’s kinda like, well, (Do not make fun of me, I get nervous sometimes.) do I live in a state. Is the United States a state? (It must be because it has the base word state in the name.) Is Minnesota a state? (Probably not because it doesn’t even mention the word state.) Is Waseca a state? (It most likely is just because of the element of surprise.) Anyway there is Gabey Staceys opinion

    1. Gabey

      I am very super pooper dooper sorry for my last comment. After the statement do I live in a state, there should have been a question mark, not a period.

  4. Norberto Rodriguez

    P Rico have to be a State , Because P Rico dont produce anything no sugar,no rice etc,etc, must of people living in there live out of food stamp,people get Kill and must of time they dont get the killer and if you have money ,The judge will let you go,Sample Ana Cacho,Macho Camacho Killer and other Other wise P Rico is all screw up.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>